Connecting...

Back to Articles
Blog Img

The AI Paradox: High Adoption, Low Trust – Bridging the Gap

Artificial intelligence (AI) is quickly becoming a big part of how we work here in Australia. Companies are jumping on board, hoping AI will make things run smoother, spark new ideas, and boost the bottom line. The numbers show it: two-thirds (65%) of Aussie employers are now using AI, and almost half (49%) of us are using it regularly on the job. Mid-sized companies are especially hopeful, expecting their AI investments to pay back four times over as they look for that competitive edge.

But there's a catch. While businesses are eager, many Aussie workers aren't quite sold on AI. There's a real gap in trust and understanding. Fresh data from April 2025 shows that even though half (50%) of Australians use AI often, only 36% actually trust it, and a whopping 78% are worried about things going wrong.

For businesses, this gap between the company push and how ready people feel creates a tricky situation that could stop AI from delivering its promised perks and even open businesses up to new problems. For professionals with sought-after AI skills, it shines a light on the importance of environments that foster trust and effective AI use. Tackling this paradox head-on is crucial for companies to succeed and for skilled individuals to thrive.

Digging Deeper: Australia's AI Trust Problem

Australia's hesitation around AI trust (just 36% are willing) puts us behind many other countries. Even more telling, only 30% of Aussies think the benefits of AI outweigh the risks – that's the lowest score globally. This isn't just vague worry; it comes from real concerns. Nearly four out of five (78%) are anxious about negative side effects, and over a third (37%) have personally seen or experienced problems like AI getting things wrong, spreading misinformation, job skills becoming less valuable, or privacy slipping away.

Professor Nicole Gillespie from Melbourne Business School puts it plainly: people need to trust AI for it to be truly accepted and used well. Right now, that lack of trust seems to be holding us back. Australians are reporting fewer benefits from using AI (55%) compared to the global average (73%). It suggests we're using AI cautiously, maybe just scratching the surface, which means we're missing out on the bigger productivity and innovation wins. For businesses, this hesitation directly threatens the return they expect on their AI investments.

The Skills Lag: Why AI Know-How Matters for Organisations and AI Talent

Adding to the trust problem is a big gap in AI know-how across the workforce. Knowing how AI works, what it can't do, and how to use it the right way is super important, but Australia's a bit behind here. Only 24% of us have had any AI-related training (compared to 39% globally). Over 60% admit they don't know much about AI (vs. 48% globally), and less than half (48%) feel confident they have the skills to use AI tools effectively (vs. 60% globally).

What's really surprising is that Australians also show the least interest globally in learning more about AI. Why the lack of curiosity? Maybe current tools seem simple, or perhaps the low trust makes people hesitant to dive deeper. Whatever the reason, it's a hurdle. Professor Gillespie points out that AI literacy isn't just about doing your job better; it builds trust, acceptance, and the ability to critically judge what AI produces. For professionals developing AI talent, this skills gap highlights the need for continuous learning to stay ahead in a tech landscape needing 1.3 million workers by 2030. For employers, this gap means your team might not be ready to use AI safely and get the most out of it.

Here’s a quick look at where Australia stands compared to global averages:

Metric

Australia

Global Average

Willingness to Trust AI (%)

36%

Higher

Belief Benefits > Risks (%)

30% (Lowest)

Higher

Received AI Training/Education (%)

24%

39%

Confidence in Skills to Use AI (%)

<48%

60%

Reported Experiencing AI Benefits (%)

55%

73%

​

Workplace Roulette: The Real Risks for Businesses and Staff

This mix of low trust and low understanding isn't just talk; it's causing real risks in Aussie workplaces right now. Without enough guidance, employees are sometimes doing things with AI that put their companies at risk – operationally, ethically, and security-wise.

Almost half (48%) admit using AI in ways that go against company rules, like uploading sensitive company info into free public tools (think ChatGPT). A lot of people (57%) also tend to trust AI output without double-checking it, which leads to mistakes in their work (59%). On top of that, many admit hiding their AI use or passing off AI-generated work as their own. This often happens because clear rules are missing. Even though generative AI is the most popular type (used by 71%), only 30% of organisations actually have a policy for it.

KPMG Australia's John Munnelly nails it: many companies are rushing into AI without setting up the necessary "transparency, accountability and ethical oversight – all of which are essential ingredients for trust". For businesses, this lack of rules and know-how creates a minefield of potential errors and security issues. For employees, trying to use AI without clear guidelines or training can easily lead to mistakes or breaking rules they didn't even know existed.

Bridging the Divide: What Businesses and AI Talent Can Do

Getting on top of Australia's AI trust and skills gap is essential if we want to get the best out of AI without the headaches. This needs leaders to step up with smart plans focusing on people, clear rules, and the right company vibe.

For Business Leaders and Organisations:

  1. Get Serious About AI Training: Go beyond the basics. Roll out solid training that covers how to use AI practically, check its output critically, understand its limits, handle data safely, and think ethically. Make sure the training is easy to access, engaging, relevant to different roles, and ongoing.

  2. Set Clear AI Rules: Create and share straightforward guidelines on what's okay and not okay when using AI tools, especially the generative ones. Cover things like handling sensitive data, when to disclose AI use, the need to verify AI work, and IP issues. Make sure everyone knows the rules.

  3. Build a Safe Space to Learn: Foster an environment where people feel safe to try AI responsibly, ask questions, admit mistakes (even AI-related ones), and raise concerns without fear of blame. Encourage sharing both wins and fails with AI to help everyone learn.

  4. Use AI Responsibly: Adopt frameworks that put fairness, transparency, accountability, and human oversight first when using AI. Think about AI assurance checks – like monitoring accuracy – which 83% of Aussies say would make them trust AI more. Keeping up with government guidelines helps too.

  5. Lead with Openness: Be upfront about how and why AI is being used, including what it can and can't do. Treat AI adoption like any major change, making sure your team is on board and sees it as a helpful tool, not just tech forced upon them.

For Professionals Building AI Expertise:

  1. Make AI Skills a Priority: Actively look for training to understand AI tools, their ethical side, and how to use them effectively and critically in your field.

  2. Know Your Workplace Rules: Understand and follow your organisation's AI guidelines. Advocate for clarity where policies are lacking.

  3. Think Critically: Don't just accept what AI tells you. Get into the habit of checking facts and judging AI content before relying on it.

  4. Look for AI-Ready Employers: Seek out companies that invest in AI training, have clear rules, and promote responsible AI use – environments where your AI talent can flourish.

Turning the AI Paradox into Potential for Everyone

Australia's at a crossroads with AI. We're adopting it quickly, which is exciting, but our workforce's trust and skills haven't quite caught up. This mismatch won't work long-term. It creates risks, slows down productivity boosts, and stops us from really making the most of the AI revolution. If we ignore the people side of things – the trust issues, the skills gaps, the worries – we're asking for mistakes, security problems, and AI projects that just don't deliver.

Leaders need to act now. Seriously investing in AI skills, setting clear rules, encouraging open chats and a safe space to learn, and being upfront about AI aren't just 'nice-to-haves' – they're essential for making this AI shift work.

For organisations, fixing the trust and skills gap isn't just about avoiding problems; it's a chance to get ahead. Companies that get this right can build a team that truly works with AI, driving smart innovation and getting a real edge. Creating this AI-ready team needs smart talent strategies and a commitment to always learning – attracting and retaining top AI talent is key.

For professionals with AI expertise, getting comfortable with AI tools and choosing employers who use them responsibly will be key to navigating the future job market and finding rewarding opportunities.​

Let's Bridge the Gap Together

Whether you're a business leader trying to figure out AI adoption and secure the right AI talent, or a professional looking to apply your AI skills in a forward-thinking organisation, FinXL is here to help.

  • Clients: Discover how our tailored workforce solutions, strategic insights, and access to skilled professionals can help you bridge the AI trust and literacy gap in your organisation and integrate top-tier AI talent.

  • AI Talent: Connect with FinXL to explore opportunities with leading companies embracing AI responsibly, where your skills are valued and you can contribute to meaningful innovation.

Contact FinXL today to chat about how we can support your AI journey and help turn this paradox into real potential.

​

Sources: